Downtown Vital Signs

Downtown Vital Signs

By: Patrick Kennedy

Introducing the State of Downtowns Index, a benchmark of 127 American downtowns across five dimensions of urban health (click link above for free dropbox access).

For four years, the story of the American downtown has been told in a single number: office vacancy. It is the metric that fills headlines, drives commercial real estate anxiety, and shapes the way city leaders talk about their urban cores. And it is real. Vacancy in many central cities remains at or near record highs, and the surplus of empty office space is both a defining challenge and a defining opportunity.

But office vacancy is a symptom, not a diagnosis. A downtown is not an office park with a skyline. It is a living system: residents, workers, visitors, streets, storefronts, transit, tax base, and civic institutions all interacting. Reducing that system to a single occupancy figure is like judging a person’s health by their cholesterol number alone. It tells you something. It doesn’t tell you enough.

That is the gap the State of Downtowns Index was built to close.

Remote work is a premise, not a problem

Most downtown strategy still quietly assumes the commuters are coming back. We think that is the wrong bet, and we have built the Index on the opposite assumption.

Remote work is likely with us for the foreseeable future. The downtowns that succeed will not be the ones that restore the weekday commute. They will be the ones that stop depending on it. The surplus of underused office space is not a problem to be reversed. It is the opening to rebuild downtowns as complete, livable neighborhoods rather than nine-to-five business districts.

So the Index leans hardest on a different set of signals: the residents who actually live in and around downtown, and the share of people who both live and work there. Those measure what sustains a downtown across the full day and week, independent of where any employer happens to be headquartered. It is not a coincidence that these turn out to be the indicators that differentiate downtowns most across the entire dataset. The measure and the thesis point to the same conclusion.

What the Index measures

The Index benchmarks 127 U.S. downtowns and scores each one from 0 to 100 across five thematic modules, the vital signs of a downtown:

     

      • General Downtown Health: the baseline condition of the core

      • Downtown Housing: the residential base that keeps a downtown alive after 5 p.m.

      • Sustainability: the environmental and transportation efficiency of the core

      • Vibrancy: the density of jobs, income, and street-level activity

      • Good Bones: the underlying infrastructure and physical fabric a downtown has to build on

    Each city receives a composite Downtown Health Score, a diagnostic band (Thriving, Healthy, Stable, At Risk, or Critical), and a full profile showing exactly where it is strong and where it is struggling. Every score is normalized across the national cohort, so a city sees not just how it is doing, but how it stands relative to its peers.

    You can try it yourself. The free public tool lets you compare up to five cities side by side on the public-facing signals: downtownvitalsignsmvp.netlify.app

    Article content

     

    Sample image from one of the five proprietary diagnostic modules

    What the rankings reveal

    San Francisco ranks first, and the reason is not what anyone expects. Its residents retain more disposable income after housing and transportation than any city in America. That is the whole argument for walkable, transit-rich urbanism in a single number: when you do not need a car, the housing premium pays for itself. But San Francisco also carries the single starkest weakness in the Index. Ownership attainability sits in the 9th percentile nationally, and downtown is measurably the more affordable part of the city, meaning the core is not attracting San Francisco’s higher earners, who live in the neighborhoods instead. The best downtown in America is one almost nobody can buy into.

    On the other hand, Midtown Manhattan, which we expected to come out on top, was dinged for being stable, not a bad thing, but one of our metrics is Momentum. We were interested in which downtowns have been growing in population since 2000. However, its strength as the primary employment hub for an entire country helps bring Brooklyn and Jersey City upward in the rankings.

    Size is not destiny. Some of the largest cities in the country post downtown scores far below what their population would predict, sprawling metros that grew enormous without ever concentrating a core. Meanwhile Portland, Maine, with roughly 68,000 residents, is the strongest overperformer in the entire Index, scoring like a city several times its size. It has no large neighbor to borrow from. Its advantage is structural: an intact pre-automobile street grid that was never torn out. Population fills a city. It does not, by itself, build a downtown.

    Proximity is an asset, but it is not a strategy. Jersey City lands in the national top ten, and it earns it. Its Newark Avenue pedestrianization is one of the most successful car-free main streets in the country. But the honest diagnosis names the engine: this is a downtown built on a ten-minute train ride to the largest job market in America. Jersey City has done the hard local work superbly, and it is also borrowing a weight class. Portland’s route is the one most cities can actually copy. And it still has room to improve as our prescriptions suggest.

    Article content

     

    Sample comparison from the Housing Module showing downtown Brooklyn, Jersey City, and Midtown Manhattan

    Every downtown is strong somewhere. Even the lowest-ranked cities score well on at least one module. That is not a consolation prize. It is the entire point. A downtown weak on housing but strong on Good Bones has a completely different prescription than one with the opposite profile. The ranking tells you where a city stands. The modules tell you what to do about it.

    From diagnosis to prescription

    This is where the Index becomes more than a scoreboard.

    A ranking that only sorts winners from losers is of limited use to the people who actually run downtowns. What a mayor, a downtown alliance, or a developer needs is not a grade. It is a direction. The State of Downtowns Index is powered by the Downtown Vital Signs diagnostic engine, built specifically to turn a score into a strategy.

    For any city in the dataset, Downtown Vital Signs can:

       

        • Isolate the weak module: pinpoint whether the challenge is housing, mobility, infrastructure, or economic vibrancy, rather than lumping it all under “struggling.”

        • Benchmark against the right peers: to understand why Portland, Maine punches above its weight, you have to compare it to cities of similar size, not to New York or Chicago. Peer-to-peer rankings are coming in future editions.

        • Generate tailored prescriptions: pair each diagnosis with concrete, sequenced interventions, from near-term tactical moves to long-term structural bets, drawn from what comparable cities have actually done.

      This is the difference between telling a city it ranks 47th and telling it that its downtown residential base is thinning, that a comparable peer reversed the same trend through a variety of policy initiatives and design interventions, and that here are the three steps to begin. One is a headline. The other is a plan.

      A note on what a single score can and cannot do

      A composite blends strengths with weaknesses, and in doing so it flattens the very differences that matter most. Two downtowns can reach the same number by opposite routes, and their prescriptions would look nothing alike.

      That is why the real diagnosis lives in the modules and in the DVS radar profiles, which chart each downtown’s individual indicators as a distinct shape rather than a single figure. This Index is not a scorecard for its own sake. It is a tool to help each city build the best downtown for that city.

      The opportunity ahead

      The surplus of underused downtown space is genuinely an opportunity, but only for the cities that can see clearly which of their systems are healthy enough to build on and which need intervention first. Reinvestment is expensive, political capital is finite, and a downtown cannot fix everything at once. The cities that recover fastest will be the ones that spend limited resources where the diagnosis says they will matter most.

      That is what a diagnostic tool is for. The State of Downtowns Index shows where every downtown in America stands today. Downtown Vital Signs shows each one where to go next.

      The State of Downtowns Index is produced by Downtown Vital Signs. Explore the free public tool at https://downtownvitalsignsmvp.netlify.app/. To see the full rankings, methodology, and individual city profiles, or to commission a custom diagnostic for your downtown or adding additional cities, contact patrick@thehumanecosystem.city or brandon@3blstrategies.com.

      Article content

       

      Top 20 rankings for 2026 (out of 127 cities)

      Introducing the State of Downtowns Index, a benchmark of 127 American downtowns across five dimensions of urban health (click link above for free dropbox access).

      For four years, the story of the American downtown has been told in a single number: office vacancy. It is the metric that fills headlines, drives commercial real estate anxiety, and shapes the way city leaders talk about their urban cores. And it is real. Vacancy in many central cities remains at or near record highs, and the surplus of empty office space is both a defining challenge and a defining opportunity.

      But office vacancy is a symptom, not a diagnosis. A downtown is not an office park with a skyline. It is a living system: residents, workers, visitors, streets, storefronts, transit, tax base, and civic institutions all interacting. Reducing that system to a single occupancy figure is like judging a person’s health by their cholesterol number alone. It tells you something. It doesn’t tell you enough.

      That is the gap the State of Downtowns Index was built to close.

      Remote work is a premise, not a problem

      Most downtown strategy still quietly assumes the commuters are coming back. We think that is the wrong bet, and we have built the Index on the opposite assumption.

      Remote work is likely with us for the foreseeable future. The downtowns that succeed will not be the ones that restore the weekday commute. They will be the ones that stop depending on it. The surplus of underused office space is not a problem to be reversed. It is the opening to rebuild downtowns as complete, livable neighborhoods rather than nine-to-five business districts.

      So the Index leans hardest on a different set of signals: the residents who actually live in and around downtown, and the share of people who both live and work there. Those measure what sustains a downtown across the full day and week, independent of where any employer happens to be headquartered. It is not a coincidence that these turn out to be the indicators that differentiate downtowns most across the entire dataset. The measure and the thesis point to the same conclusion.

      What the Index measures

      The Index benchmarks 127 U.S. downtowns and scores each one from 0 to 100 across five thematic modules, the vital signs of a downtown:

      • General Downtown Health: the baseline condition of the core
      • Downtown Housing: the residential base that keeps a downtown alive after 5 p.m.
      • Sustainability: the environmental and transportation efficiency of the core
      • Vibrancy: the density of jobs, income, and street-level activity
      • Good Bones: the underlying infrastructure and physical fabric a downtown has to build on

      Each city receives a composite Downtown Health Score, a diagnostic band (Thriving, Healthy, Stable, At Risk, or Critical), and a full profile showing exactly where it is strong and where it is struggling. Every score is normalized across the national cohort, so a city sees not just how it is doing, but how it stands relative to its peers.

      You can try it yourself. The free public tool lets you compare up to five cities side by side on the public-facing signals: downtownvitalsignsmvp.netlify.app

      Article content
      Sample image from one of the five proprietary diagnostic modules

      What the rankings reveal

      San Francisco ranks first, and the reason is not what anyone expects. Its residents retain more disposable income after housing and transportation than any city in America. That is the whole argument for walkable, transit-rich urbanism in a single number: when you do not need a car, the housing premium pays for itself. But San Francisco also carries the single starkest weakness in the Index. Ownership attainability sits in the 9th percentile nationally, and downtown is measurably the more affordable part of the city, meaning the core is not attracting San Francisco’s higher earners, who live in the neighborhoods instead. The best downtown in America is one almost nobody can buy into.

      On the other hand, Midtown Manhattan, which we expected to come out on top, was dinged for being stable, not a bad thing, but one of our metrics is Momentum. We were interested in which downtowns have been growing in population since 2000. However, its strength as the primary employment hub for an entire country helps bring Brooklyn and Jersey City upward in the rankings.

      Size is not destiny. Some of the largest cities in the country post downtown scores far below what their population would predict, sprawling metros that grew enormous without ever concentrating a core. Meanwhile Portland, Maine, with roughly 68,000 residents, is the strongest overperformer in the entire Index, scoring like a city several times its size. It has no large neighbor to borrow from. Its advantage is structural: an intact pre-automobile street grid that was never torn out. Population fills a city. It does not, by itself, build a downtown.

      Proximity is an asset, but it is not a strategy. Jersey City lands in the national top ten, and it earns it. Its Newark Avenue pedestrianization is one of the most successful car-free main streets in the country. But the honest diagnosis names the engine: this is a downtown built on a ten-minute train ride to the largest job market in America. Jersey City has done the hard local work superbly, and it is also borrowing a weight class. Portland’s route is the one most cities can actually copy. And it still has room to improve as our prescriptions suggest.

      Article content
      Sample comparison from the Housing Module showing downtown Brooklyn, Jersey City, and Midtown Manhattan

      Every downtown is strong somewhere. Even the lowest-ranked cities score well on at least one module. That is not a consolation prize. It is the entire point. A downtown weak on housing but strong on Good Bones has a completely different prescription than one with the opposite profile. The ranking tells you where a city stands. The modules tell you what to do about it.

      From diagnosis to prescription

      This is where the Index becomes more than a scoreboard.

      A ranking that only sorts winners from losers is of limited use to the people who actually run downtowns. What a mayor, a downtown alliance, or a developer needs is not a grade. It is a direction. The State of Downtowns Index is powered by the Downtown Vital Signs diagnostic engine, built specifically to turn a score into a strategy.

      For any city in the dataset, Downtown Vital Signs can:

      • Isolate the weak module: pinpoint whether the challenge is housing, mobility, infrastructure, or economic vibrancy, rather than lumping it all under “struggling.”
      • Benchmark against the right peers: to understand why Portland, Maine punches above its weight, you have to compare it to cities of similar size, not to New York or Chicago. Peer-to-peer rankings are coming in future editions.
      • Generate tailored prescriptions: pair each diagnosis with concrete, sequenced interventions, from near-term tactical moves to long-term structural bets, drawn from what comparable cities have actually done.

      This is the difference between telling a city it ranks 47th and telling it that its downtown residential base is thinning, that a comparable peer reversed the same trend through a variety of policy initiatives and design interventions, and that here are the three steps to begin. One is a headline. The other is a plan.

      A note on what a single score can and cannot do

      A composite blends strengths with weaknesses, and in doing so it flattens the very differences that matter most. Two downtowns can reach the same number by opposite routes, and their prescriptions would look nothing alike.

      That is why the real diagnosis lives in the modules and in the DVS radar profiles, which chart each downtown’s individual indicators as a distinct shape rather than a single figure. This Index is not a scorecard for its own sake. It is a tool to help each city build the best downtown for that city.

      The opportunity ahead

      The surplus of underused downtown space is genuinely an opportunity, but only for the cities that can see clearly which of their systems are healthy enough to build on and which need intervention first. Reinvestment is expensive, political capital is finite, and a downtown cannot fix everything at once. The cities that recover fastest will be the ones that spend limited resources where the diagnosis says they will matter most.

      That is what a diagnostic tool is for. The State of Downtowns Index shows where every downtown in America stands today. Downtown Vital Signs shows each one where to go next.

      The State of Downtowns Index is produced by Downtown Vital Signs. Explore the free public tool at https://downtownvitalsignsmvp.netlify.app/. To see the full rankings, methodology, and individual city profiles, or to commission a custom diagnostic for your downtown or adding additional cities, contact patrick@thehumanecosystem.city or brandon@3blstrategies.com.

      Article content
      Top 20 rankings for 2026 (out of 127 cities)